“Your trusted neighborhood local,” Nightly’s is a swanky spot that redefines your typical Upper East Side hangout. This place strikes the perfect balance between trendy and neighborhood-friendly, offering a relaxed yet upscale atmosphere. Whether you’re grabbing a drink or enjoying a meal, Nightly’s nails that sweet spot between casual and chic.
The Burger: Black Tie Burger (Honorable Mention). 8oz Pat Lafrieda Dry-aged gourmet burger, secret sauce, white cheddar, and caramelized onions on a brioche bun.
Pro Tip: The Marry Me Chicken has received a lot of praise, though it’s just an okay choice. The cocktail and drinks menu, however, is a standout. The Negroni on tap is a refreshing, light orange concoction with a beautiful color. Even if you’re not a fan of Negronis, this one might surprise you. The Sangiovese wine, bottled in-house, is also delicious.
The Occasion & Vibe: With Drinks. Nightly’s has a trendy yet true neighborhood feel. The spacious dining room and beautiful bar offer a comfortable spot for both walk-ins and reservations, with the kitchen staying open late. The back corner table, draped in velvet, adds a cozy touch, while a playlist that includes the likes of De La Soul and People Under the Stairs sets a great vibe. It’s a cool, unique spot with upscale logos that give it a distinctly elevated feel—definitely not your typical UES venue. A cheetah motif runs throughout, adding a quirky, fun touch to everything from the menus to the coasters.
The Location: Upper East Side, 78th Street & 2nd Avenue.
